Dennis Chi Aristotle Professor Bett Dec. 8, 2003 Specifically, I would like to look at how he thinks we can “demonstrate” things, especially with regards to his account of coming to know the first things. I also find interesting the tension between the pragmatic nature of his argument against skepticism and the stringent requirements of truth which he demands. I.e. if what is demonstrated must be everlasting, what is a false conclusion that we use and act on in our everyday lives? If Aristotle came to know, for example, that the world was round, or that disease was caused by microscopic living creatures, how would that affect his pragmatic approach to skepticism? Aristotle’s Theory of Knowledge In this essay, I will attempt to show how Aristotle justifies this view of coming to know, as well as point out what I see to be some fundamental problems with his approach. According to very first line of Aristotle’s Posterior Analytics, “all teaching and all intellectual learning come about from previous knowledge” (37). He first uncontroversial applies this to both inductive and deductive logic, since both types of logic rely on “examples or on argumentations” (37). In other words, his statement of prior knowledge simply says that there is some knowledge prior to the conclusion of any new knowledge which leads to that new knowledge. This prior knowledge comes in two flavors : presupposed principles like the Principle of Excluded Middle, and an understanding of what the thing spoken of signifies. The latter of these two seems an obvious requirement of coherent argument, while the former seems more doubtful in terms of his initial statement that “all intellectual learning come[s] about from previous knowledge” (37). This first example that he gives here of something with both of these characteristics of prior knowledge is a triangle which we must both understand and presuppose the existence of.
To link to this page, copy the following code to your site:
All Papers Are For Research And Reference Purposes Only!
You may not turn these papers in as your own! You must cite our web site as your source!
