Ritualists defence
Ritualists defence When the cognition from the positive statement such as he is kings person is produced, the cognition from the corresponding negative statement such as he is not kings person should not be allowed to be produced. And such a goal can be achieved automatically in our ritualists theory as the cognition from the negative statement wherein the absence of the master servant relation conditioned by the king, is related to the person, is directly contradictory to the cognition from the positive statement wherein the master servant relation, conditioned by the king, is related to the person. ... And that is why they do not approve of the ritualists claim that the reference to such relations of non identity as master servant relation is a necessary condition for the cognition of non identity. ... Status of Master-servant relation (svatva) Ritualists theory Ritualists hold that, master servant relation (svatva), like any other syntactico semantical relation, must be accepted to be the referent qualifier, prSkaia* i. ... Objection to the ritualists theory Main objection of logicians, however, to the ritualists position that such semantical relation as master servant relation is a referent qualifier is that the same involves the heaviness of assumption; that is to say that when the master servant